Journalist Catherine Wanjeri Kariuki was sporting a brilliant yellow hoodie beneath her beige-coloured vest emblazoned with the phrase “PRESS” when three pellets fired by Kenyan police lodged in her left thigh.
Kariuki is a Kenyan broadcast reporter with Kameme TV and Mediamax. She was standing with fellow journalists on the intersection of Pandit Nehru Highway and Kenyatta Avenue in downtown Nakuru, a metropolis in western Kenya, when she was shot with a less-lethal weapon at shut vary.
Much less-lethal weapons also called non-lethal weapons are usually utilized in crowd management conditions by police however can doubtlessly be deadly relying on how they’re used.
Footage and pictures captured on the scene on July 16 reveals {that a} police officer shot in direction of a gaggle of eight unarmed folks together with a number of journalists from a shifting police car.
Using drive seems to violate a number of guidelines outlined in Kenya’s Nationwide Police Service Act. The Sixth Schedule of the Act outlines that:
- “A police officer shall all the time try to make use of non-violent means first and drive might solely be employed when non-violent means are ineffective…”
- “The drive used shall be proportional to the target to be achieved, the seriousness of the offence, and the resistance of the individual in opposition to whom it’s used…”
- “When the usage of drive leads to accidents -the law enforcement officials current shall present medical help instantly and until there are good causes, failing to take action shall be a legal offence…”
Bellingcat was not capable of determine the police officer accountable for the taking pictures, nonetheless footage seems to indicate it was the individual seated behind the driving force’s seat of the police car, licence plate GKB905Y.
Greater than 40 folks have been killed since anti-finance invoice demonstrations started in June this yr. Kenya’s police chief resigned final month over the police response to the protests however accountability for police brutality has been laborious to return by in Kenya. Amnesty Worldwide and Human Rights Watch have beforehand documented a number of incidents of extreme use of drive by police and the unbiased physique fashioned to research the problem – the Unbiased Police Oversight Authority (IPOA) – has constantly struggled to safe convictions in opposition to law enforcement officials.
Nakuru County Police Commander, Samuel Ndanyi instructed Bellingcat the incident involving Kariuki was “unlucky” however denied police fired from their autos at reporters. He mentioned the case has been handed over to IPOA to research.
Bellingcat contacted IPOA to ask in regards to the standing of the investigation, however they’d not responded at time of publication.
Journalist Catherine Wanjeri Kariuki instructed Bellingcat she desires the case to be correctly investigated in order that extra journalists don’t change into a goal of police.
“Journalists are drained and fed up of being suppressed and being instructed to maintain quiet once they shouldn’t.”
Whereas there have been extra deadly incidents throughout the anti-finance invoice protests in Kenya, video proof from this case reveals precisely how a police weapon was used, significantly injuring a journalist who posed no risk.
Protests Unfold Throughout Kenya
Widespread avenue protests started in Nairobi and shortly unfold throughout the nation on June 18, as folks took to the streets to oppose a finance invoice that may elevate taxes.
At the least 23 folks have been killed in violent clashes between police and protesters at parliament in Nairobi. Protests have continued even after Prime Minister William Ruto withdrew the invoice and fired the vast majority of his cupboard. Kenya’s Nationwide Fee on Human Rights (KNCHR) stories at the very least 50 folks have been killed since protests started.
On the day Kariuki was shot, protesters had gathered within the downtown of Kenya’s third largest metropolis, Nakuru.
Demonstrators in Downtown Nakuru
Protesters started to assemble on Tuesday morning alongside Kenyatta Avenue.
Protesters may be seen marching down the road with whistles, and vuvuzela. Armed Kenya Protection Forces (KDF) and police may also be seen on the streets.
Plenty of KDF forces have been deployed to Nakuru in late June to protect the federal government workplace within the metropolis, they are often seen in footage sporting camouflage however some deployed police have been additionally in camouflage.
A livestream by KTN Information captured a small variety of protesters chatting with the media at 1:55pm native time, simply exterior the Faulu Microfinance Financial institution, positioned right here on the intersection of Kenyatta Avenue and Pandit Nehru Highway.
Native media additionally confirmed footage of protesters being dispersed with tear gasoline alongside Kenyatta Avenue.
All through the day information crews have been current on the intersection of Kenyatta Avenue and Pandit Nehru Highway in downtown Nakuru. Footage reveals a small variety of protesters on the web site and visitors persevering with to maneuver via the realm at about 2pm.
About an hour later, footage captures 4 mounted law enforcement officials flip onto Kenyatta Avenue and head north alongside Pandit Nehru Highway.
Police Shoot in direction of Kariuki and Different Journalists
At the least two movies captured the precise second of the shooting- from barely totally different angles. One video was captured from amongst the journalists in entrance of Faulu Microfinance Financial institution – the opposite from the alternative aspect of the intersection.
You may watch the footage side-by-side, under:
Sources: Mutembei Archived from Fb and Twitter.
Within the footage we will see the mounted police flip up Pandit Nehru Highway. Whereas the police car GKB905Y follows behind.
The car then drives straight down Kenyatta Avenue for yet another block (heading east), earlier than it stops close to a Complete Energies petrol station and performs a U-turn. The quantity ‘226’ may be seen below its aspect mirror.
Many retailers look like closed between Faulu Financial institution and Complete Energies – the place the police car turns round – and the road seems to be largely empty, aside from numerous what look like KDF troops strolling alongside the road.
Along with police and KDF forces, footage and pictures present that a number of journalists have been positioned on the intersection of Kenyatta Avenue and Pandit Nehru, specifically in entrance of Faulu Financial institution, right here: -0.283751, 36.073842– a group of a number of journalists stood with their notepads and cameras.
Two of them, together with Kariuki, have been sporting distinctive press jackets, one other was holding a TV digicam.
Kariuki, may be seen in yellow hoodie and beige press vest, moments previous to the taking pictures because the jeep drives previous the primary time.
Not one of the eight folks standing in entrance of the Faulu Financial institution are armed, and they don’t seem to pose any risk to the KDF forces or police.
Plenty of armed KDF may be seen strolling subsequent to the journalists in entrance of Faulu Financial institution and at no level do they look like threatened by the folks gathered on the nook.
Simply earlier than GKB905Y turns the nook, footage reveals a shot being fired from the again of the car. This seems to return from the individual positioned instantly behind the driving force’s seat, though the face of the officer can’t be made out.
After the shot is fired, the car turns the nook into Pandit Nehru Highway and pictures filmed on the alternative aspect of the road reveals Kariuki – in her yellow hoodie and press vest- collapse to her knees.
In the meantime, footage captured from Faulu Financial institution – simply subsequent to Kariuki- reveals the police officer positioned behind the driving force’s seat elevate up their visor, apparently to get a greater have a look at the scene. Bellingcat was unable to determine the officer accountable for the taking pictures.
Earlier than leaving the realm, a 3rd shot is fired from the police car because it drives up Pandit Nehru Highway.
As Kariuki collapses to the bottom, a digicam approaches, and at the very least two entry wounds may be seen on her left thigh.
A second man in denims and a brown jacket – seen standing subsequent to Kariuki- may also be seen on the bottom, apparently additionally sustaining accidents from the shot fired. Nonetheless his accidents can’t be clearly made out within the footage.
Each Kariuuki and the person and loaded onto motorbikes and pushed from the scene.
Weapons Carried by Police in GKB905Y
4 law enforcement officials may be made out, sitting at the back of police car GKB905Y. Some are sporting helmets with “Police” written on them.
At the least two officers look like armed with the identical weapon – a comparatively older mannequin of a tear gasoline launcher. The distinctive white canister may be seen loaded within the weapons at varied factors within the footage and tear gasoline is fired from the car at varied factors within the footage.
The individual – seated instantly behind the driver- is tough to make out and we will’t see the weapon they have been carrying. However we will clearly see a ‘puff’ from a gunshot fired from this place. Measuring the gap between the car and the group’s location signifies the shot was fired from lower than ten metres away. Bellingcat obtained photos of the three pellets later faraway from Kariuki’s leg at a hospital – suggesting the weapon was a mannequin which fires pellets or rubber bullets of some variety.
Kariuki’s medical report from the Provincial Common Hospital – Annex the place she underwent surgical procedure states:
“Affected person introduced after being concerned in a taking pictures sustained [three] penetrating accidents to the left thigh.”
An Amnesty Worldwide paper on the usage of kinetic weapons, reminiscent of rubber bullets and different projectiles, outlines that these weapons ought to solely be utilized in “distinctive circumstances” and regarded on the higher degree of the usage of drive scale, slightly below deadly firearms.
“This implies their use can solely be justified whether it is to forestall one other individual from being severely injured and never for any decrease threat than this…Moreover, it’s unacceptable {that a} kinetic affect projectile will injure different individuals who don’t current such a risk.”
The Kenya Human Rights Fee (KHRC) has reviewed footage of the taking pictures. Ernest Cornel, communications lead at KHRC, instructed Bellingcat:
Using drive violates the foundations outlined in Kenya’s Nationwide Police Service Act and violates worldwide requirements, such because the United Nations Fundamental Rules on the Use of Pressure and Firearms by Regulation Enforcement Officers, which emphasise that drive must be used solely when completely vital and in a method that’s proportional to the risk.
“The actions depicted clearly violate worldwide pointers on the usage of less-lethal weapons and drive, in addition to worldwide legal guidelines that defend freedom of expression, peaceable meeting, and affiliation.”
Along with the pointless and extreme use of drive, the firing in direction of journalists and different civilians represents a risk to the rights of freedom of expression and peaceable meeting, he mentioned.
Cornel mentioned Kenyan police must evaluate how the usage of drive has been deployed in response to protests, including that the taking pictures of Kariuki suggests a broader concern with police response techniques throughout protests. The officer accountable must be suspended from obligation whereas the investigation is carried out and the officer’s superiors must also be held accountable if there may be proof they failed to forestall misconduct or condoned it.
Moreover KHRC urges IPOA to conduct a swift investigation into circumstances of police misconduct.
“Accountability will not be solely about addressing the actions of the person officer but additionally about analyzing the systemic points that allowed the misconduct to happen.”
Different Incidents that Day
Along with the taking pictures of Kariuki, police in Nakuru have been reportedly concerned in plenty of different incidents within the metropolis that day.
A younger man was allegedly injured by a rubber projectile fired by police earlier that day. Bellingcat was unable to verify how he was injured however footage reveals him being carried by three folks from a store in direction of a minivan. Bellingcat geolocated the video to round -0.284510, 36.070994 – roughly 300 metres from the place Kariuki was shot on Kenyatta Avenue.
Bellingcat additionally chronolocated the footage to round 11:35 – 12:25.
Moreover Citizen TV Kenya posted a video round 17:35 which seems to indicate the CCTV footage from the Chosen Era Church, exhibiting police members contained in the church and folks mendacity on the bottom.
Citizen TV Kenya reported that protesters took refuge contained in the church when law enforcement officials stormed it and detained one individual. The time stamp within the footage reads 14:59.
An indication that reads “Chosen Era Church” may be seen on the prime of the body. Supply: Twitter.
The Taking pictures from Kariuki’s Level of View
Kariuki instructed Bellingcat that protesters have been concentrated in a small space of town and he or she was shifting between Kenyatta Avenue and different principal roads when she was shot.
A tear gasoline canister had been fired in her route earlier that day, nevertheless it occurred whereas she was close to Kenyan law enforcement officials, so she assumed it was an accident, she mentioned.
Kariuki had been reporting from the streets for about two hours when she was shot in entrance of Faulu Financial institution.
“It was solely journalists and a few law enforcement officials who have been manning one of many microfinance banks, round that place.”
As a result of it occurred so shortly she couldn’t determine the officer who shot at her.
Kariuki instructed Bellingcat that she desires the case to be correctly investigated. Reaching accountability on this case is vital due to the broader risk going through journalists, she mentioned. Kariuki has filed a grievance with IPOA however is apprehensive that the investigation might drag on and that nobody will likely be finally held accountable.
“It’s my prayer that one month doesn’t elapse earlier than I’m given an replace.”
“I discuss press freedom as a result of I’m not the one journalist who has been attacked.”
Police Response
Nakuru County Police Commander, Samuel Ndanyi instructed Bellingcat he had not seen footage of the taking pictures and denied police fired from their car at reporters.
“We didn’t have any law enforcement officials firing from the shifting car in direction of the journalists.”
He mentioned police have been deployed to the realm to disperse protesters, and described the incident as “fairly unlucky”.
“No police officer left his or her home with an intention that they have been going to do what occurred,” Ndayni instructed Bellingcat.
He didn’t reply questions on whether or not use of drive pointers have been adopted. He mentioned plenty of officers had recorded statements in regards to the incident however he mentioned he didn’t know if the officer concerned had been suspended.
Ndanyi instructed Bellingcat the case is at present being investigated by IPOA and mentioned he was awaiting the outcomes of this probe.
Bellingcat contacted IPOA to ask in regards to the standing of the investigation and when the findings could be printed, however they’d not responded at time of publication.
Bellingcat additionally contacted The Workplace of the Lawyer Common and Division of Justice to ask about this incident and wider problems with police accountability, however had not acquired a response at time of publication. Up to now nobody has been held accountable for the taking pictures.
Since Kairuki was shot, the Worldwide Press Affiliation (IPA) of East Africa reported that at the very least three journalists have been injured whereas protecting anti-finance invoice protests in Nairobi earlier this month once they have been hit with tear gasoline fired at shut vary.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the flexibility to hold out our work depends on the sort assist of particular person donors. If you want to assist our work, you are able to do so right here. It’s also possible to subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and observe us on Twitter right here and Mastodon right here.
