Word: Explosive ordnance (EO) are extraordinarily harmful. By no means method them except you’re explicitly skilled to take action. When posting about doubtlessly explosive objects on-line, don’t encourage others to work together with them. Should you come throughout any potential EO, name the police or different related authorities.
Landmines, rockets, bombs, grenades and different explosive weapons that have been fired however didn’t explode can stay harmful for many years after wars and conflicts finish.
Generally often called unexploded ordnance (UXO), these weapons can detonate with out warning, killing or injuring civilians lengthy after conflicts have ended.
International estimates range, however in 2023, the Landmine Monitor recorded 4,710 individuals injured or killed by landmines and explosive remnants of battle. In Ukraine alone, between February 2022 and Might 2023, the HALO belief recognized 855 civilians that have been harm or killed in 550 mine-related accidents.
The rise of battle imagery on social media has offered civil society and researchers invaluable materials to determine explosive ordnance (EO), together with UXO. Nonetheless, this has additionally elevated the danger of misinformation and disinformation surrounding weapons use. Misidentifications of EO may end up in pretend narratives spreading on-line, false accusations in instances of battle, and bodily hurt or dying to people throughout clearance efforts.
What this information covers
EO is outlined by Oxford Reference as “any munition that incorporates explosives, together with bombs and warheads; guided and ballistic missiles; artillery, mortar, rocket, and small arms ammunition; mines, torpedoes, and depth and demolition expenses”.
This information goals to supply a place to begin to decipher the origin and traits of EO featured in social media imagery as precisely as potential. Doing so can present proof to counter false or dangerous narratives, and help with post-conflict clear up efforts.
There are a lot of various kinds of EO, however this information will concentrate on determine a number of the extra generally seen ones, close to current open-source assets that may be discovered on-line. We’ve got compiled an inventory of a number of the most helpful on-line assets for this goal, which you will see on the finish of this information.
We is not going to cowl naval ordnance as these are very hardly ever present in social media imagery, apart from the often washed up anti-ship mine.
The information additionally focuses on UXO discovered as full objects, and doesn’t embody detailed evaluation of remnant items of shrapnel after explosive ordnance has detonated and functioned as designed, or craters and harm left from such weapons. Whereas it could be potential to determine EO post-detonation based mostly on clues similar to seen textual content, and a number of the suggestions on this information will also be utilized to such instances, that is typically harder than for intact objects.
You will need to be aware that on-line identifications of munitions are all the time preliminary and can must be adopted by thorough comparisons and checks.
Beginning your investigation
Step one in investigating any on-line imagery is to make sure that it’s genuine. Any imagery or content material on-line may very well be altered or posted with deceptive data, which might lead to a misidentification of EO or the unfold of false data. Thus, verifying the authenticity and originality of any content material is necessary earlier than exerting effort and time to determine any munitions seen within the imagery. You’ll be able to consult with Bellingcat’s information to social media verification for recommendation on get began with this.
If the merchandise within the imagery is excessive sufficient decision and never broken or soiled, a reverse picture search could be a good subsequent step. This may reveal earlier efforts to confirm the identical picture, in addition to potential matches for the sort or mannequin of the weapon proven. Reverse picture searches usually are not restricted to Google – Bellingcat has detailed the core variations between a number of reverse picture search engines like google and yahoo and outlined methods for utilizing them for investigations right here.
Earlier than investigating additional you may additionally need to first verify the Open Supply Munitions Portal, which has lots of of verified pictures of EO which you’ll search by means of based mostly on the place and when the pictures have been reported to have been taken.
Figuring out options
After getting established that the picture is genuine and that the article it reveals has not been beforehand recognized, a better examination can typically present clues on what the article proven is.
- Textual content
Fairly often bigger munitions shall be labelled or stamped with the precise mannequin sort and different data, similar to manufacture date and manufacturing lot. If any writing is seen on the merchandise or every other associated objects close by, similar to ammunition crates, this may be a straightforward strategy to decipher the precise mannequin.
For instance, weapons produced by NATO international locations would usually carry a CAGE code (Industrial and Authorities Entity Code), a novel five-digit quantity distinctive identifier assigned to suppliers to numerous authorities or defence companies. These codes, which may be discovered by means of an on-line database of US Division of Protection’s Protection Logistics Company (DLA), have been used to hint the origin of EO in Syria and Yemen.
Because of the huge number of EO fashions that exist, there isn’t any centralised useful resource for figuring out the that means of labels and markings, even when they’re clearly printed on the article. Nonetheless, there are numerous guides that target particular sorts of EO, or these of sure origins. For instance, the Collaborative ORDnance information repository (CORD) has a database of over 5,000 entries associated to figuring out landmines and different EO. One other instance is Bomb Techs With out Border’s Primary Identification Information to Ammunition in Ukraine, which covers each identified merchandise of ordnance used within the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
- Colors
The color of the merchandise of EO may assist determine its sort and mannequin. Totally different colors typically signify the kind of explosive throughout the merchandise however may designate their use instances, similar to apply or coaching rounds, that are marked with a blue background and white writing by NATO nations.
Non-profit GlobalSecurity.org has a listing of color codes utilized by the previous Soviet Union, the US and different NATO international locations. There’s additionally a helpful information to determine bullets – together with explosive rounds – by the colour-coded markings on their suggestions right here.
- Form, dimension and different distinctive options
If the merchandise has no instantly figuring out marks, label, stamps, or colouring, the following step is to take a look at its form and dimension.
It’s possible you’ll consult with the beneath slideshow for definitions of the sorts of EO talked about beforehand, their frequent shapes and instance pictures.
The descriptions are not at all exhaustive and solely signify a abstract of the most typical fashions in every class. EO is available in all shapes, sizes, and types. The choice tree beneath may help within the identification course of.
Relying on the standard of and extra context within the imagery, it could possibly generally be potential to measure the article’s approximate dimensions. A number of the instruments and methods you should utilize to do that are defined in this information.
Contextual clues
If the the sort or mannequin of the EO proven in a picture remains to be ambiguous, there are a number of clues that may assist to additional slender down the scope of analysis and supply helpful context.
- Location
Sure sorts of weapons are utilized in a restricted variety of places. Geolocating the place the picture was taken can due to this fact assist researchers determine the kind of EO.
For instance, Russia has not carried out any vital floor operations in its invasion within the Western a part of Ukraine. Imagery from the far West of Ukraine, due to this fact, is extra more likely to present principally superior weapons deployed from the air, similar to long-range cruise missiles or aerial bombs.
Cluster munitions, which disperse a number of explosive submunitions or bomblets over a large space, are identified to have been utilized in 41 international locations and 5 territories because the finish of World Warfare II. Such munitions are banned beneath an worldwide treaty signed by greater than 100 international locations because of the indiscriminate hazard they pose to civilians, which helps slender down the potential international locations of origin for such weapons.
To be taught extra about geolocating imagery, consult with our earlier guides right here and right here.
- Timing
The timing of the incident may be fairly necessary too.
For instance, if an occasion in Ukraine occurred previous to 2016, it’s much less unlikely to be of Western origin, because the Ukrainian Armed Forces acquired little Western assist previous to 2016.
The timing can be necessary because it can provide us a selected cut-off time to search for arms transfers that occurred previous to the occasion. The Stockholm Worldwide Peace Analysis Institute or SIPRI, supplies an open database of all transfers of main typical arms from 1950 to the newest full calendar 12 months, so figuring out the time that the article was discovered can slender down the vary of EO that might presumably be proven within the imagery.
Equally, some weapon methods may be discounted if the imagery is dated previous to a sure 12 months because of the identified improvement and deployment dates of some methods. For instance, the PTKM-1R, a brand new Russian landmine, was proven publicly first in 2021 and used for the primary time in Ukraine the next 12 months. Thus, if the imagery is from earlier than these years, it’s extremely unlikely to be this particular mannequin. Nonetheless, a small probability stays {that a} weapon may very well be used earlier than it’s publicly introduced.
Investigators use numerous methods to find out when a photograph or video was taken, in a course of often called “chronolocation”. These may embody observing the size of shadows, or evaluating satellite tv for pc imagery from totally different dates to see if landmarks seen within the pictures have modified over time. Bellingcat has outlined a few of these methods in a earlier information on chronolocation.
- Different objects
Social media pictures or movies hardly ever concentrate on one particular object. If there are a number of objects within the goal imagery, these can generally additionally act as clues to figuring out the EO.
There’ll typically even be different objects associated to the EO proven round it in pictures, similar to shell casings, fuses, shrapnel, ammunition containers or equipment. These will help determine the sort and mannequin of EO. In lots of cases, the containers used to hold the ordnance could have figuring out marks. Landmines will typically have security caps made from plastic which are eliminated earlier than emplacement. These will typically be left close by, thus serving as a possible clue.
Instance identification course of
Having outlined a number of the methods you should utilize to determine EO in social media pictures, let’s stroll by means of a sensible instance following a number of the steps above.
Under is a screenshot of a social media publish reportedly exhibiting an EO merchandise within the Budennovsky district of Donetsk, Japanese Ukraine. This was discovered on the favored Типичный Донецк channel on Russian social media web site VKontakte, which often reviews on preventing within the space.
- Does the article have any writing on it? The reply is not any. The merchandise seems degraded and rusted, and sadly any figuring out marks are both on the facet within the earth or have eroded due to make use of or the climate.
- What colors function on the merchandise? The item is a lightweight inexperienced color but in addition closely rusted in direction of the precise of the picture. Given the degraded state of the article it’s troublesome to determine its authentic color and any colouring bands that may have been current.
- What’s the object’s form and dimension? Does it have any distinctive options? The item is rectangular in form with simply recognisable fins and spigots in direction of the left facet of the article. It has round marks on the precise of the widest a part of the physique that are additionally recognisable as obturating rings – used to seal gases in for artillery – regardless of the heavy rusting.
Referring to our resolution tree, we are able to determine it as a kind of mortar ammunition. This may be confirmed by a verify on the Open Supply Munitions Portal with a seek for different confirmed pictures of mortars. Nonetheless, we’re unable to slender this right down to a selected mannequin with out extra sources, as the article proven is extremely corroded and there’s no seen stamping or writing.
Different instruments and assets
This information has targeted on figuring out sorts of explosive ordnance in imagery originating on social media. Nonetheless, given the complexity of and big variance in sorts of EO, it could be essential to consult with particular assets to determine them. We’ve got collected a number of the most useful ones in a repository.
The repository is a residing doc with new assets added as soon as up to date or made public. Every useful resource is tagged by the class and origins or location of use of the munitions it covers. A quick description for every is offered as properly. Most are free and open-access, though a small quantity require registration or have paid choices.
Past human identification of objects in imagery, laptop imaginative and prescient and machine studying are slowly being built-in into the EO recognition course of. Whereas improvement remains to be ongoing, a number of start-ups – VFRAME and Tech4Tracing – are engaged on this, which might make it simpler for investigators to recognise objects not solely in social media imagery, but in addition in dwell drone imagery within the close to future.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work depends on the type assist of particular person donors. If you want to assist our work, you are able to do so right here. You can even subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our E-newsletter and comply with us on Twitter right here and Mastodon right here.
