This text is the results of a joint investigation by Bellingcat and Lloyd’s Checklist. The Lloyd’s Checklist model of this piece could be discovered right here.
A Russian flagged vessel was granted clearance by a UN inspection physique to name at a Houthi-controlled port after surreptitiously exporting grain from a western sanctioned terminal in occupied Crimea, an investigation by Bellingcat and Lloyd’s Checklist has discovered.
The majority provider, Zafar (IMO: 9720263), switched off its Automated Identification System (AIS) – that permits it to be tracked by delivery companies and which business vessels are mandated to maintain on until at risk – when it visited the Port of Sevastopol in Could this 12 months.
Satellite tv for pc imagery revealed the vessel’s presence on the port.
Zafar then switched AIS on after leaving Sevastopol and stored it on for its journey to Yemen, in line with Lloyd’s Checklist Intelligence information. It docked in Djibouti in late June the place it was given clearance by the United Nations Verification and Inspection Mechanism for Yemen (UNVIM).
It’s not clear if UNVIM knew that the cargo had come from occupied Crimea given Zafar sought to masks the very fact it went there.
Whereas there isn’t any advised illegality with this cargo, consultants say it creates an ungainly scenario the place a UN mechanism has waved via a grain cargo from occupied Ukrainian territory regardless of Russia’s ongoing invasion of Ukraine and the truth that member nations have repeatedly voted in opposition to Russia’s actions in direction of its neighbour.
The UN Normal Meeting has handed plenty of resolutions in opposition to Russia’s invasion of Crimea and japanese Ukraine relationship way back to 2014. It additionally demanded Russia withdraw all army forces from Ukrainian territory following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. However in contrast to some resolutions from the Safety Council, on which Russia sits and has a veto, Normal Meeting votes are not legally binding.
The Port of Sevastopol is presently below United States and United Kingdom sanctions, whereas the terminal that Zafar docked in at Sevastopol is below European Union sanctions.
Importantly, nonetheless, there are not any UN sanctions on the Port of Sevastopol or Russia.
Daniel Martin, a companion on the Holman Fenwick Willan legislation agency who specialises in worldwide commerce sanctions informed Lloyd’s Checklist: “[if] you have a look at this from the attitude of the worldwide coverage goals of getting meals into Yemen and stopping the entry of arms then UNVIM is fulfilling its mandate.”
“However should you have a look at the larger image, then it’s seemingly that western international locations would like that this occurs with out enriching sanctioned international locations,” he added.
Materials on the UNVIM web site outlines that it has acquired “voluntary contributions and lively assist” from the likes of the EU, US Division of State, USAID and the Ministry of International Affairs for the Netherlands because it was arrange in 2015.
It was not clear precisely the place the grain carried by Zafar to Yemen was harvested, however some farmers in occupied japanese Ukraine have beforehand accused Russian forces of stealing grain that was subsequently exported.
Yemen is likely one of the world’s poorest international locations. The last decade-long civil conflict between the Saudi-backed internationally recognised authorities and Iranian-backed Houthi forces has led to 1000’s of deaths and a humanitarian disaster. The UNHCR states thousands and thousands have been displaced and there’s a threat of widespread famine.
UNVIM facilitates the motion of business gadgets to Yemeni ports not below the federal government’s management, whereas additionally making certain compliance with a UN arms embargo. As of 2018, UNVIM grants clearance for the Houthi-controlled ports of Hodeidah and Saleef (also referred to as As-Salif).
Service provider ships are required to submit a clearance request with supporting documentation, reminiscent of payments of lading and clearance from load port, to UNVIM previous to their arrival. Offered there are not any points UNVIM will grant clearance. If there are any suspicions relating to the ship’s actions, crew, paperwork, or prohibited cargo on board then UNVIM will examine the ship.
The UN Workplace for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs confirmed to Lloyd’s Checklist that Zafar did certainly report back to UNVIM for inspection and was cleared on June 21, with a certificates following on June 22, 2024. It stated it was then as much as the Saudi-led EHOC to make the ultimate choice to grant clearance to Zafar based mostly on UNVIM’s inspection report.
OCHA declined to offer additional details about Zafar together with whether or not the port of loading was recognized to be Sevastopol on the time of clearance being authorised and if the vessel was bodily inspected. The Saudi Ministry of Defence didn’t reply to emailed questions from Lloyd’s Checklist earlier than publication.
Russia has been express about its purpose to develop its grain exports – on the expense of Ukrainian grain exports – with the intention to win international affect and goodwill. The nation’s President, Vladimir Putin said in 2023 that Russia had “the capability to switch Ukrainian grain, each commercially and as free assist to needy international locations.”
Zafar arrived in Saleef simply a few days earlier than a go to of a Houthi delegation to Moscow in early July the place points together with Yemen’s Civil Warfare have been mentioned.
The Russian authorities and Ministry of International Affairs didn’t reply to emailed questions in regards to the cargo earlier than publication, nor did the operator of Zafar.
When approached for remark, the US State Division referred Lloyd’s Checklist to UNVIM with regard to this particular incident however reaffirmed its assist for the work of the company.
Monitoring Zafar’s Journey to Yemen
In December final 12 months, Zafar was noticed by Bellingcat and Lloyd’s Checklist delivering grain loaded on the Port of Sevastopol to Bandar-e Emam Khomeini in southern Iran, thus making it a vessel of curiosity.
It was seen on AIS information within the Kerch Strait, a slender physique of water between occupied Crimea and mainland Russia, from mid-March till March 30.
But at this level it despatched monitoring information intermittently, disappearing on April 13.
This has been widespread observe for ships visiting the Port of Sevastopol ever since western sanctions have been launched in 2015, and particularly for the reason that onset of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 – because the beneath graphic detailing ships that visited Sevastopol with AIS off however which have been captured on satellite tv for pc imagery in simply the primary 12 months of Russia’s full scale invasion emphasises.
Satellite tv for pc pictures taken between mid-Could and late-Could 2024 certainly seem to indicate Zafar docked within the Port of Sevastopol.
In addition to a picture from Could 17, one other picture from Could 24 seems to match the measurements and distinctive specs of Zafar such because the yellow cranes in addition to its distinct chimney and bridge.
A comparability with a picture gathered throughout a earlier investigation emphasises these similarities.
Upon leaving Sevastopol, Zafar started broadcasting AIS as soon as extra whereas safely again within the space south of the Kerch Strait the place AIS indicators had beforehand ceased. With out the help of satellite tv for pc imagery, it could have appeared to have remained on this space.
It transited the Bosphorus Strait on June 1, with photographs from the bottom matching AIS information documenting Zafar’s actions.
These pictures additionally spotlight the distinctive options of the ship that have been seen in satellite tv for pc pictures from Sevastopol such because the yellow cranes, chimney, bridge and place of the lifeboats.
Zafar could possibly be tracked by AIS during the Mediterranean, on to the Suez Canal and the Purple Sea earlier than arriving in Djibouti on June 16. It stayed in anchor simply off shore earlier than docking on June 19.
After its port name in Djibouti, Zafar sailed to Saleef, in Yemen. It spent one other few days anchored off the coast there earlier than docking on the Saleef Port on June 30.
AIS information confirmed the ship’s place whereas satellite tv for pc pictures present a ship with the identical dimensions and similar options as Zafar.
Apparently, the compartments are open and seem to have been emptied. Vans could be seen lined up alongside the vessel whereas not less than one crane seems to be hovering over constructions on the pier.
At time of writing, Zafar stays docked at Saleef. It could possibly be seen there in satellite tv for pc imagery and on AIS monitoring information.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work depends on the type assist of particular person donors. If you need to assist our work, you are able to do so right here. You may also subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and observe us on Twitter right here and Mastodon right here.
