supply: @ScottMGreer on X
Scott Greer has a latest YouTube podcast Don’t Take the Welfare Capsule, denouncing the embrace of welfarism on the dissident proper. Greer is a reactionary and an elitist who promotes White identification primarily based on preppy WASPs and fraternities. Whereas a level of elitism is required, the truth is that nation membership WASPs and frats typically have pretty normie political beliefs. Nevertheless, Greer isn’t essentially a full-on financial libertarian.
Scott Greer argues {that a} section of White Nationalists need Whites to grow to be the brand new Blacks. This isn’t solely fallacious, as dissident proper White guys really feel completely alienated from America, very similar to Blacks did up to now. Dissident proper accounts will promote happening welfare as reparations for White males being systematically discriminated in opposition to. There’s additionally this meme of simply discover a lady from a trailer park and churn out a lot of youngsters on welfare to boost the White beginning fee.
This mentality is in stark distinction with bougie White racism that seeks to keep away from the underclass, therefore the meme “wignats.” Nevertheless, the dissident proper is split between calls to exploit the anti-White system and protesting that happening welfare is just for non-Whites. To not point out that many poorer Whites refuse welfare out of pleasure, even when they’re maybe naïve in regards to the system.
There’s a termite philosophy that encourages folks to undermine a system and society that’s unjust. Conservatives are cucks for eager to power everybody to contribute to a society that’s essentially at odds with their values. Whereas low-status Whites haven’t any motive to be loyal to the system, the broader challenge is that American society is low belief and atomized, and simply an financial zone that doesn’t justify loyalty. To not point out that the system is corrupt, rigged in favor of the ultra-wealthy, with welfare for the wealthy and companies way more obscene than welfare for the poor.
The dissident proper disproportionately appeals to low-status Whites, who’re extra to the left on economics than conservatives. Nevertheless, a number of these takes are from alienated center class nerds, with boring workplace jobs, quite than White lumpen proles residing in trailer parks. There’s additionally a proletarianization of the normie proper, as Greer factors out. For example, conservatives typically say don’t go to school and fetishize being a working class schlub. Regardless, it’s good to see the Proper transfer away from Reaganism/Paul Ryanism.
supply: @bizlet7
Individuals justifiably view work as a rip-off, and if in case you have zero prospects of constructing it to the higher center class, why trouble? Thus many make a calculated choice to be on welfare quite than be a part of the working poor. Scott Greer is true that welfare isn’t some path to energy, neither is it ravenous the beast. Most individuals on welfare have a low high quality of life. It comes all the way down to accepting a managed decline quite than a very revolutionary act.
Whereas the best is a no strings hooked up UBI, welfare forces folks to give up their autonomy to the State, in addition to serves as a security valve to maintain the proles from rebelling. For example, welfare type of neutered Blacks after the racial uprisings of the ‘60s and ‘70s. Nevertheless, welfare may be some cushion from cancel tradition, as I’ve by no means heard of anybody shedding welfare advantages for his or her views. In distinction, Charlottesville protesters misplaced their low-status retail jobs after getting doxed. The large challenge with welfare isn’t political cancelation however quite that folks lose their advantages for working and, thus are stored in a state of perpetual poverty. That is one more reason why welfare must be changed by UBI.
The concept that welfare recipients are moochers off the center class is nonsense. It’s because the State prints cash and points treasury bonds as debt to cowl the funds. The aim of taxation isn’t really to fund authorities packages, however quite to instill compliance to and keep the legitimacy of the system. If somebody is on welfare they aren’t stealing from taxpayers, although they’re contributing considerably to inflation and debt, which makes it a lot much less private.
There’s this trope from the Proper that America can’t have a Western European-style welfare state due to how various we our. They’ve it completely backward, as a beneficiant security web and assembly folks’s primary materials wants is the one means you may keep a multi-ethnic society with out everybody turning on one another. We will pull this off so long as we maintain on to our World Reserve Foreign money standing, although AI would possibly generate sufficient wealth sooner or later to take care of a beneficiant welfare state.
Boomer Conservatives nonetheless act like it’s the 80s with Welfare Queens residing giant, because the scope of welfare has been drastically restricted since Invoice Clinton’s neoliberal austerity reforms. Whereas welfare is barely dysgenic, the dysgenic impression is exaggerated by the Proper. The fertility fee for the lumpen proletariat is barely above substitute stage, however nothing just like the rightwing stereotype that the standard lady of shade on welfare has 10 youngsters every.
I reject the argument that welfare is dangerous for the entrepreneurial spirit, as these bold sufficient to grow to be profitable typically are usually not going to go on welfare within the first place. Although there are clearly some outliers of rags to riches tales. The concept that People are lazy is nonsense as productiveness has gone means up. The economic system can get by with not everybody working and a section of hyper-ambitious strivers can raise up the useless weight.
The issue is that the job market doesn’t completely match society’s genetic range. For example, the underside 10-20% in IQ are principally unemployable. To not point out tremendous socially awkward or autistic folks, except they will make it in STEM, are typically screwed. And even then, STEM fields at the moment are flooded with H1bs. We simply don’t have a system that may match folks up with jobs that they’re most suitable with.
As a result of America makes it so depressing to be within the backside half, there are simply as many lower-class people who find themselves striving to maneuver up, as there are who’ve completely given up on life. I detest the hyper moralism round welfare and want the difficulty might be mentioned in additional sensible phrases, as folks reply to incentive buildings.
