Bachelor Nation has continued to search for solutions since Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist introduced their break up throughout an emotional interview on Good Morning America.
The twosome, who tied the knot throughout a televised marriage ceremony in January, defined on GMA that they deliberate to maneuver in collectively however couldn’t agree on a location. (Us Weekly confirmed previous to their interview that Gerry had been residing at his lake home in Indiana whereas Theresa had been residing at her house in New Jersey.)
“We checked out properties in South Carolina, we thought-about New Jersey, and we simply checked out properties after house,” Theresa stated in the course of the April broadcast, “however we by no means received to the purpose the place we made that call.”
Hours after The Golden Bachelor couple introduced they referred to as it quits, Us broke the information that Gerry had filed to dissolve their marriage in his hometown of Petersburg, Indiana.
Scroll all the way down to learn the hypothesis as to why Gerry and Theresa separated:
Gerry’s Previous
Gerry made headlines days earlier than The Golden Bachelor finale aired in November 2023 when The Hollywood Reporter printed a bombshell report that he dated a number of girls following the loss of life of his first spouse, Toni, who died in 2017. One of many girls accused Gerry of fat-shaming her, which he subsequently denied in an interview with The Los Angeles Instances.
After Gerry and Theresa introduced their plans to divorce, some Bachelor Nation followers speculated that the reasoning was because of his previous. Theresa, nevertheless, denied that rumor in the course of the GMA broadcast.
“Gerry had already mentioned that with me,” Theresa shared. “He had defined it to me earlier than the report was ever launched, so we had been good with that. That didn’t play into it.”
Gerry and Theresa Can’t ‘Depart’ Their Households
The Golden Bachelor season 1 contestant Susan Noles, who additionally officiated Gerry and Theresa’s marriage ceremony, prompt their households could have contributed to their break up. (Gerry and Theresa have separate youngsters and grandchildren from their earlier relationships.)
Noles and fellow The Golden Bachelor costar Kathy Swarts overtly mentioned the separation throughout an episode of their “Golden Hour” podcast, which they posted through Instagram. When a person commented on the clip, “Why did they break up so fast?” Noles replied, “Neither certainly one of them can go away their households.”
Gerry and Theresa Argued About Her Job
Weeks earlier than asserting their break up, Gerry and Theresa shared that her job had triggered a pressure of their relationship. “I nonetheless work, in order that’s the hurdle,” Theresa stated on a March episode of the “Expensive Shandy” podcast.
Earlier than filming The Golden Bachelor, Theresa famous that she knowledgeable her work that she would solely be gone for 2 weeks as a result of she didn’t anticipate to remain awhile on the present.
“I truthfully thought, ‘Oh, let me simply get by means of the primary evening,’” she stated. “And I stayed and I stayed and I stayed, and my employer was so good to me. And earlier than I left, I form of stated, ‘Don’t fear, I’m not going to go away you.’”
Theresa added that her profession contributed to the explanation why the twosome had been long-distance after exchanging vows. Gerry, for his half, stated he would “undergo phases” relating to how he felt about Theresa’s work.
“I assume the troublesome half is I went on to the present to seek out my accomplice, and I’ve been retired for a very long time. I needed enjoyable [and] journey. I needed to go do [things],” he stated. “So that’s the crux of it, proper now, is when does that begin? I believe the residing association is actually secondary to the liberty of having the ability to go and revel in life and do. That hurdle remains to be there, and proper now, we’re coping with it. It’s simply one thing we’re gonna must discover a means round.”
Life-style Variations
One other potential purpose for The Golden Bachelor couple’s break up may have stemmed from their life-style variations. Podcast host Kate Casey claimed she had particulars from a supply whose son’s girlfriend is buddies with Gerry’s youngest granddaughter.
“He’s saying he needed the divorce as a result of she was too ‘uppity’ for him and used the instance of she wouldn’t pump her personal gasoline and hated the place he lived,” Casey stated in a clip of her “Actuality Life With Kate Casey” podcast posted through Instagram. “Everybody from the state of New Jersey is aware of you legally can’t pump your personal gasoline, you’ll be able to’t, somebody pumps your personal gasoline for you.”
On the opposite facet of issues, a supply informed Us that Theresa’s inside circle wasn’t stunned by the break up as they didn’t see eye to eye on a number of life-style choices. Individuals journal beforehand reported that the pair had “been preventing since after the marriage.”
Us Weekly reached out to ABC for touch upon Gerry and Theresa’s divorce.
Theresa’s Alleged Indiana Remark
Throughout a Could 2024 episode of the “Nearly Well-known” podcast, Ben Higgins shared a “rumor” about how an alleged remark Theresa made whereas visiting Gerry in Indiana could have performed a component of their breakup.
“‘Wow, take a look at all this lovely untouched land. Take into consideration what may very well be achieved in the event that they developed it. Condos, workplace buildings, flats. Take into consideration the cities that would congregate in these open fields and take into consideration the folks that might be eager about transferring right here,’” Ben claims Theresa remarked whereas driving by means of cornfields. “And take a look at that lake. There’s a lake with solely corn fields round it. Take into consideration in the event that they construct up a resort the place folks may trip to.’ And Gerry’s remark again to her, once more, a rumor, was, ‘You don’t take land from a farmer.’ And that was the beginning of them realizing that they didn’t see the world the identical means.”
In accordance with Ben, who’s from Indiana, “This was an enormous begin to them disagreeing on how they noticed the world and what they imagined for the world and the way they needed to speculate into the world.”
Regardless of his podcast cohost, Ashley Iaconetti, accusing Ben of making the rumor, he maintained that the story was allegedly true. “I can not speak about my sources,” he said. “I’ve sources that keep in contact and concerned they usually’re in every single place.”